Apr 102014
 

GPSvsPhone

When it comes to how runners log their workouts, there seems to be two different lines of thought. The first is to use a GPS heart rate monitor watch; the second is to use a Bluetooth heart rate monitor strap along with an app on your phone. So which one is better? What are the pro’s and con’s of each? Well, that’s a good question – I’m not sure there is a right answer. Clearly it depends on the individual. So today I thought I’d cover the basics for those of you who are getting ready to make the decision. So let’s compare the pro’s and con’s of each approach:

GPS Heart Rate Monitor Watch

Garmin-210

Pro’s

  • Smaller
  • Easier to see during your workout
  • You don’t need to carry your phone
  • GPS data is typically more accurate that the phone, providing more accurate distance and pace information
  • Many GPS watches can pair with a footpad accessory for indoor running

Con’s

  • More expensive. A typical GPS HRM costs anywhere from $200 to $500
  • Once you bought it, you are stuck with its features and software

 

 

Heart Rate Monitor Strap, app and Phone

Screen Shot 2014-04-09 at 8.36.56 PM

Pro’s

  • If you already own a phone, this is typically a cheaper solution
  • Since you are already carrying your phone, you can use it to listen to music
  • You can change apps if you don’t like the one you are using

Con’s

  • You have to carry your phone with you, either in a pocket or some purchased carrier
  • Harder to see the screen/data when you’re running
  • Sometimes the GPS receiver and data is not as accurate
  • Analysis software used to monitor and store your workouts may be more limited

 

To help with the decision, here are three questions think about:

  • Do I want to carry my phone with me? This may not be a bad idea when you’re out running. As far as which one has the edge –  I think this could go either way.
  • How much am I willing to spend? If you already have a phone, this may be the cheaper solution. I give the edge to the phone on this one.
  • How important is performance and accuracy? This includes ease of use, features,viewability, accuracy, advanced features, ect. I would give the edge to the GPS watch on this one.

So here’s how I would decide:

If I was just getting into running, I may opt for a low cost heart rate monitor strap, and use a free or low cost app on my phone. If I’ve been running for a while, or a serious runner, I would buy the GPS watch, which is easier to use. That’s just my opinion – you need to decide for yourself.

Either way, check out our reviews on GPS watches, heart rate monitor straps, and phone apps.

That’s all for now.

Enjoy the workout.

John

 Leave a Reply

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>